PlotBertram successfully convinces Jessie to act as his girlfriend to a high school reunion. The lies lead them both into trouble. Meanwhile, Ravi and Luke steal a game and lie about it. Emma and Zuri help him return the game.
- Debby Ryan as Jessie Prescott
- Peyton List as Emma Ross
- Cameron Boyce as Luke Ross
- Karan Brar as Ravi Ross
- Skai Jackson as Zuri Ross
- Kevin Chamberlin as Bertram Winkle
- This episode garnered 1.6 million viewers.
- The title is a parody of Edgar Allan Poe's short story The Telltale Heart.
- Luke says, 'You're not supposed to walk like an Egyptian towards them!', a reference to the song 'Walk like an Egyptian' by the band The Bangles
- When Emma showed Jessie and Bertram how she remembers something by writing them on her hand, she showed them her right hand. It was shown in several episodes (e.g. Help Not Wanted) that Emma is right-handed. How did she write something on her right hand?
| To view the The Telltale Duck gallery, click here.
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.